Two Ways to be “For”

A business leader once told me the hardest thing to be is a mid-size business. When I need a toaster, I’ll likely go one of two ways. Amazon maximizes the ease of the experience. One platform absorbs all the coordination, logistics, and information, so I’m functionally shopping at every store at once, and whatever I choose shows up at my door. Or I’ll go to the local shop, where the experience is personal. There’s shared community, human connection, and when it’s done well, someone responsive to my story and what I need. The mid-size business can’t match Amazon’s ease at scale, and it can’t match the local shop’s relationship. It’s stuck between two things it can’t be.

The same thing is true of those of us who aspire to be “for” something bigger than ourselves.

At the person-to-person level, being for someone is a relational commitment. It means being for their story, their needs, and their capacity (passions, gifts, time, whatever they personally have to give) with whatever capacity we have available. Relationships move at the speed of trust. In honor of the late Dolly Parton: “you can’t make old friends.”

At the scale of a community, being for people means something different. A mayor who is for their city or a pastor who is for their congregation isn’t promising to listen to thousands of individual stories, personally respond to every need, and draw out every person’s individual passions and gifts. Nobody can keep that promise. The commitment is to arrange for it to happen, building the centralized resources, infrastructure, and coordination so that care and connection can reach people the leader will never personally meet.

Both are real, and both are useful. We even have a high tolerance for where something lands on this spectrum. No one expects the mayor to sit down with every resident, so no one feels betrayed when it doesn’t happen. The frustration comes from the dissonance of being promised one kind of “for” and receiving the other. Most of us have been in a room that claimed to be “for” us, where any attempt to bring a story, a passion, or especially a need was met with a polite and often unspoken sentiment of “oh, yeah, that’s not really what we do here.” The relational promise got made. The infrastructure to back it up never got built.

It’s certainly not a new tension. In Acts 6, the widows in one part of the community were being overlooked in the daily distribution of food. The apostles didn’t wave the complaint away, and they didn’t try to wait on every table themselves. They gathered the community, had seven trusted people chosen to oversee the work, and stayed devoted to prayer and the ministry of the word. The need got met because someone arranged for it to be met. Arranging wasn’t a retreat from caring for those widows. It was how the care actually reached them.

What is new and unique is that problem being applied to the highest connectivity moment in human history. Community used to be confined by proximity. The car, the telephone, the internet, and the smartphone each widened the scope, and now we’re reconciling a new one: everyone, everywhere, all at once. Yet we’re experiencing systemic disconnection at the human level.

Neither kind of “for” can answer that alone. All macro gives us reach and coordination without relationship, which is connectivity without connection. All micro gives us real relationship, but nothing arranged around it to reach everyone who needs it, and the people carrying it wear out. The answer isn’t to swing the pendulum one way or the other. We have to get bigger and smaller at the same time. Bigger in the infrastructure, coordination, and shared resources we build for our communities. Smaller in the presence, attention, and trust we offer each other.

None of us can do all of it, but each of us has a place in both. Some are called to arrange, some to show up, and most of us to a bit of each. The question is whether we know which one we’re offering, and whether we’re building what makes the other possible.

 

Leave a Reply